When a defendant is facing criminal charges, they often encounter unfamiliar legal terms and complex procedures. Understanding what certain terms mean is incredibly helpful. One phrase that comes up in court is “dismissed with prejudice.” If your case is dismissed with prejudice, that means it’s closed for good.
The charges can’t be brought against you again for the same alleged offense, and the court considers the matter permanently settled.
Court Case Dismissed With Prejudice vs. Dismissed Without Prejudice
When a criminal case is dismissed, it can happen in different ways, and the legal wording makes a big difference in what happens next. If a case is dismissed with prejudice, that means it is over for good.
When a case is dismissed without prejudice, it means the prosecutor could bring the same charges again in the future. This often happens if there was a technical issue, a missing witness, or the need for more evidence. The case is closed for now, but it can be refiled.
Understanding the difference helps you know whether you can move on or the same accusations could come back later.
Who Decides if a Case Is Dismissed With or Without Prejudice?
Whether a case is dismissed with or without prejudice is usually up to the judge overseeing your case. The judge makes this decision after considering the facts of the case, the reasons for dismissal, and usually arguments from both the defense and the prosecution.
Suppose the main problem is just a technical error or the prosecutor wants more time to gather evidence. In that case, the judge is likely to dismiss it without prejudice, allowing the case to be filed again later.
Why Would a Case Be Dismissed With Prejudice?
There are certain situations when a judge might decide to dismiss a criminal case with prejudice. Here are some common examples of how this can happen:
Violation of Constitutional Rights
If law enforcement or prosecutors violate your basic rights during a criminal investigation or trial, the court may see dismissal with prejudice as the only fair solution. Examples include illegal searches of your home or car without a warrant, questioning you without reading your Miranda rights, or denying you access to a lawyer.
If a judge finds that these actions seriously harmed your ability to get a fair trial, the misdemeanor or felony charges may be thrown out for good.
Repeated Failure to Prosecute
Courts expect prosecutors to move cases forward and follow legal procedures. If the prosecution misses important deadlines multiple times, ignores court orders, or repeatedly shows up to court unprepared, the judge can view this as an abuse of the court’s time and resources.
In these cases, the judge may dismiss the charges with prejudice.
Lack of Evidence After Multiple Chances
Sometimes, prosecutors are given extra opportunities to gather or present more evidence if they initially don’t have enough. But if they repeatedly fail to provide adequate evidence to move the case forward, the judge may step in to protect you from being brought back to court for the same alleged crime multiple times.
Prosecutorial Misconduct
When prosecutors cross the line by hiding evidence that could help the defense, lying to the court, or relying on witnesses they know are not telling the truth, this undermines the fairness of the justice system.
Courts may respond to prosecutorial misconduct by dismissing the case with prejudice to send a clear message that such behavior will not be tolerated.
Contact the Criminal Defense Attorneys at Alpert Schreyer Criminal Defense Attorneys in Maryland for Help Today
For more information, contact Alpert Schreyer Criminal Defense Attorneys to schedule a confidential consultation with a criminal defense attorney. Our team is available to assist clients in Lanham, Frederick, Rockville, and Waldorf.
We proudly serve Prince George’s County, Frederick County, Montgomery County, Charles County and the surrounding areas. Visit our law offices at:
Alpert Schreyer Criminal Defense Attorneys Lanham
4600 Forbes Blvd Ste 201 Lanham, MD 20706
(301) 262-7005
Available 24/7
Alpert Schreyer Criminal Defense Attorneys Frederick
25 E Patrick St #200 Frederick, MD 21701
(301) 381-1993
Available 24/7
Alpert Schreyer Criminal Defense Attorneys Rockville
11140 Rockville Pike 550-J Rockville, MD 20852
(301) 364-3195
Available 24/7
Alpert Schreyer Criminal Defense Attorneys Waldorf
8 Post Office Rd, Waldorf, MD 20602
(301) 857-4771